Notification of the results of bidding and Contract Award

Country

Ukraine

Project Name

Serving People, Improving Health

Subproject

Oblast level services improvement in Vinnytsia oblast, aimed at improving the quality of medical care and treatment of cardiovascular diseases

Loan/Credit No.

8475-UA

Contract name

Engineering and consulting supervision for the construction

Identification Number

SPIH-QCBS-5.1.1

1.      AECOM  Ukraine  LLC (Ukraine)

2.      Consortium of companies of ART Çevre Teknolojileri Ins. Müh. Turz. Tic. Ltd. Sti. (Turkey), FCG Design and Engineering Ltd. (Finland), Metroplan Müsavirlik Mühendislik San. Tic. Ltd. Sti. (Turkey), Еxpert-Holding Ltd. (Ukraine)

3.      Consortium of companies of DELTA Projektconsult GmbH (Austria), DELTA Projektconsult Ukraine Ltd. (Ukraine) and Ukrainian and German Scientific and Production enterprise "The technical center of diagnostics and expertise" LLC (Ukraine)

4.      EPTISA Servicios de Ingeniería, S.L. (Spain)

5.      Joint Venture EUROESTUDIOS S.L (Spain), GETINSA-PAYMA S.L (Spain), TPF France (France) and UKRDESIGNGROUP LLC (Ukraine)

6.      GLEEDS Ukraine LLC (Ukraine)

1.      Consortium of companies of DELTA Projektconsult GmbH (Austria), DELTA Projektconsult Ukraine Ltd. (Ukraine) and Ukrainian and German Scientific and Production enterprise "The technical center of diagnostics and expertise" LLC (Ukraine)

2.      EPTISA Servicios de Ingeniería, S.L. (Spain)

3.      Joint Venture EUROESTUDIOS S.L (Spain), GETINSA-PAYMA S.L (Spain), TPF France (France) and UKRDESIGNGROUP LLC (Ukraine)

4.      AECOM Ukraine LLC (Ukraine)

Specific experience of the Consultant (as a firm) relevant to the Assignment

7.23

Adequacy and quality of the proposed methodology, and work plan in responding to the Terms of Reference

19.58

Key Experts’ qualifications and competence for the Assignment

35.06

including sub-criteria:

a) Expert K-1: (Consultant’s Team Leader)

6.84

b) Expert K-2: (Chief Resident Engineer)

9.38

c) Expert K-3: (Electrical Engineer)

5.93

d) Expert K-4: (HV Engineer)

4.91

e) Expert K-5: (Technologies and Equipment Engineer)

2.69

f) Expert K-6: (Construction Engineer)

3.97

g) Expert K-7: (Procurement Advisor and Legal Advisor)

1.36

Specific experience of the Consultant (as a firm) relevant to the Assignment

9.08

Adequacy and quality of the proposed methodology, and work plan in responding to the Terms of Reference

22.5

Key Experts’ qualifications and competence for the Assignment

31.33

including sub-criteria:

a) Expert K-1: (Consultant’s Team Leader)

4.93

b) Expert K-2: (Chief Resident Engineer)

6.0

c) Expert K-3: (Electrical Engineer)

5.49

d) Expert K-4: (HV Engineer)

6.5

e) Expert K-5: (Technologies and Equipment Engineer)

6.2

f) Expert K-6: (Construction Engineer)

0

g) Expert K-7: (Procurement Advisor and Legal Advisor)

2.23

Specific experience of the Consultant (as a firm) relevant to the Assignment

9.18

Adequacy and quality of the proposed methodology, and work plan in responding to the Terms of Reference

25.28

Key Experts’ qualifications and competence for the Assignment

45.29

including sub-criteria:

a) Expert K-1: (Consultant’s Team Leader)

7.35

b) Expert K-2: (Chief Resident Engineer)

13.49

c) Expert K-3: (Electrical Engineer)

6.47

d) Expert K-4: (HV Engineer)

5.25

e) Expert K-5: (Technologies and Equipment Engineer)

6.58

f) Expert K-6: (Construction Engineer)

0

g) Expert K-7: (Procurement Advisor and Legal Advisor)

6.15

Specific experience of the Consultant (as a firm) relevant to the Assignment

9.33

Adequacy and quality of the proposed methodology, and work plan in responding to the Terms of Reference

21.38

Key Experts’ qualifications and competence for the Assignment

50.49

including sub-criteria:

a) Expert K-1: (Consultant’s Team Leader)

6.39

b) Expert K-2: (Chief Resident Engineer)

13.7

c) Expert K-3: (Electrical Engineer)

6.62

d) Expert K-4: (HV Engineer)

5.99

e) Expert K-5: (Technologies and Equipment Engineer)

6.6

f) Expert K-6: (Construction Engineer)

4.95

g) Expert K-7: (Procurement Advisor and Legal Advisor)

6.27

Proposal’s price as declared

Evaluated Proposal’s price to currency of evaluation

Final combined Technical/Financial score

Ranking

EPTISA Servicios de Ingeniería, S.L. (Spain)

680,940.00 USD

14,351,469.31 UAH

84.8125

1

Consortium of companies of DELTA Projektconsult GmbH (Austria), DELTA Projektconsult Ukraine Ltd. (Ukraine) and Ukrainian and German Scientific and Production enterprise "The technical center of diagnostics and expertise" LLC (Ukraine)

1,127,926.00 EURO

41,921,339.94 UAH

69.4586

2